Single Property Finder *

* Don't have an address or mls number? Click here for Advanced Search.

Advanced Search

Not enough options with our simple search below? Click here for Advanced Search.

Most common searches

The most common searches we see, check them out, you might find something you're interested in!

We have recently purchased a canal front home on Pine Island with Erika Foye acting as our real estate agent.  Her knowledge of the region was extensive, more

Dr. K and K, Toronto, Canada

Hi Erika, Thank you for your time and patience as we navigated through the market on Pine Island.  Your considerable knowledge of the island truly helped more

Joe and Cody, New York, New Yo

We were very fortunate to meet a real estate broker during our visit to Pine Island who is a true professional: Erika Foye.  We reviewed her website more

Lewis and David, Virginia

Thanks for representing us, Erika!  We were lucky to find someone like you that is down to earth and truly represented us as buyers!

Roxane and Greg, Michigan

Working with Erika was great!  Really, she did the work and made finding just the right kind of land for a Pine Island homestead easy.  Lots of helpful more

DM, California
See all testimonials

Welcome to the internet home of All Island Realty, Inc.,   I'm Erika Foye, the broker and accredited buyer's representative for All Island Realty, Inc.

I specialize in helping buyers find the perfect property for them, here on Pine Island, in the communities of Matlacha, Bokeelia and Pine Island.  Use this site to search for properties according to your own criteria, or contact me to assist you in setting up your search criteria, email me at As of January, 2017, here are the properties for sale on Pine Island:

* 98 Gulf Access Single Family Waterfront Homes, priced from $205k - $1.4 million, median price $460,000.

*49  Off water Single Family Homes, priced from $127K - $699K, median price $265,000.

*21 Condominiums priced from $116k - $549k, median price $249,500.

*37 Manufactured homes priced from $52k-$279k, median price $190,000.

*78 Water Front home sites from $87k - $798K, median price $196,500.

*148 Off Water Home sites or larger parcels of agricultural lands, from $12,900 k - $650k, median price $25,000.

* 25 Agricultural parcels from 1 to 72 acres, priced from $44,900. - 1,316,000.  Median price $127,949.

If you'd like to receive a package of maps and general information about Pine Island, just let me know.   I'm a 14 year resident of Bokeelia and enjoy all the opportunities to be on the water (kayaking, paddleboarding, fishing), and biking on our great 17 mile bike path.  I also enjoy our wonderful library, community center, Olympic size community pool and all the local galleries and shops.  View photos of local life on Pine Island, including flora and fauna, at my blog at  Also, I just posted 2016 Pine Island Real Estate sales statistics at my blog, summarizing the $89 Million Dollars of 2016 real estate sales in the Pine Island communities of Bokeelia, Saint James City, and Matlacha in 2016.

Best, Erika Foye, President of All Island Realty, Inc. and Accredited Buyer's Representative

Email me with questions!


Welcome to natural, historic Pine Island Florida!

Market Trends

Trends regarding real estate sales in the most popular areas that you might be interested in. Click "View Graph" to see a graph of the last 18 months.

  • Community
  • Sale Price
  • 30-Day Prices